
Eighteen states and Washington, D.C. have already signed onto a pact that would hand their electoral votes to whoever wins the national popular vote — regardless of how their own citizens voted. The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact has been quietly building toward 270 electoral votes for years. After this month's blue wave handed Democrats new trifectas in Arizona, Nevada, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin, the compact is now within striking distance of the finish line.
All five of those states could push the total past 270. At that point, the Electoral College still technically exists. It just doesn't matter anymore.
The scheme works like this: once states controlling 270 or more electoral votes sign on, the compact activates. Every participating state agrees to award its electors to the winner of the national popular vote, not the state popular vote. No constitutional amendment required. No two-thirds of Congress. No ratification by three-fourths of the states. Just a workaround dressed up as reform, as reported by Just The News.
New Jersey Governor Mikie Sherrill has already endorsed gutting the Electoral College outright. "Our votes in New Jersey are worth about one fifth of what a vote in Wyoming is," Sherrill said. "That's not democracy."
The math sounds compelling until you remember what it actually means. Under this compact, if every voter in Pennsylvania chose Candidate A, but Candidate B won the national popular vote, Pennsylvania's electors go to Candidate B. The will of Pennsylvania's voters gets overridden by the will of voters in California and New York. That's the "democracy" Sherrill is selling.
Wisconsin's incoming Democratic Governor-elect David Crowley and Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro have both signaled interest in Electoral College reform — which, in the current political context, means joining the compact. With fresh Democratic trifectas in all five target states, there's no Republican legislature standing in the way. The bills just need to pass both chambers and get a gubernatorial signature.
The constitutional questions here aren't subtle. Article I, Section 10, Clause 3 of the Constitution requires that interstate compacts receive Congressional consent. The compact's backers have spent years arguing they don't need it — that this is simply each state exercising its Article II, Section 1, Clause 2 authority to choose how its electors are appointed. A voter challenged the compact in Miller v. Washington back in 2019, and the court dismissed the case for lack of standing. The Supreme Court's ruling in Chiafolo v. Washington upheld state laws constraining how electors vote, which compact supporters cite as favorable precedent.
Attorney General Todd Blanche isn't buying any of it. "It shouldn't get past the district court," Blanche said. "I am optimistic that the Supreme Court will never even have to deal with this." He added: "We will take it to the Supreme Court if we have to."
The timing matters. The Electoral College has produced a winner who lost the popular vote five times in American history — 1824, 1876, 1888, 2000, and 2016. Two of those five happened in the last quarter century, both favoring Republicans. George W. Bush in 2000. Donald Trump in 2016. Trump then won both the popular vote and the Electoral College in 2024, which should have retired the argument. Instead, Democrats watched their midterm wave materialize and saw an opening.
The compact doesn't abolish the Electoral College on paper. It just rigs the inputs so the output is predetermined. Every participating state becomes a rubber stamp for the national tally, and the system that was designed to prevent a handful of population centers from dictating terms to the rest of the country becomes a mechanism for exactly that.
Inez Feltscher Stepman, a senior policy and legal analyst at the Independent Women's Forum, put it bluntly: "It seems like the right has barely realized the importance of the fight that's about to begin."
She's not wrong. Five state legislatures. Five governors ready to sign. No constitutional amendment process standing in the way — just a legal theory that hasn't been tested at the Supreme Court level and an opposition that, by Stepman's own assessment, hasn't woken up yet.
The Founders didn't design the Electoral College because they couldn't count. They designed it because they understood what happens when political power concentrates in the places with the most people and the least accountability. The compact's supporters keep calling it democracy. The Constitution calls interstate compacts without Congressional approval something else.
That question is heading to court. The five state legislatures haven't voted yet.



